Fun fact: I ran into Adam Sessler at E3, and he said his interview with us was the VERY last he did at Rev3.It's a shame it never got published because it was really good. At GDC, he seemed a bit fed up with the reaction from people for his 6/10 review for Infamous: Second Son. Perhaps that was the straw that broke the camel's back? Personally, I like to see people using more numbers than just 7+ (except when rating my game). Game reviews are weird. If you look at metacritic for movies - they are much lower - even for stand out films.
I feel like there is some unspoken rule where game reviewers have to give games the benefit of the doubt unless they are indie or unknown. It'd be great to read a review that said, "You know, I think I've had enough Assassin's Creed", but you don't see many of those. There was some backlash against Call of Duty Ghosts, but I think it has a metacritic of 78 or so, which is not bad at all. Personally, I did NOT enjoy Call of Duty Ghosts at all. I'm not saying it's bad game, but it wasn't for me. I don't feel like it is possible to make a game for everyone, but why isn't that reflected in review scores? Okay, rant over.
Anyway, while I thought Splatoon was just Nintendo trying to get with the program and make a networked shooter, I watched a video about it today, and it seems pretty unique and interesting. Too bad they probably won't have voice chat or a decent network platform, so it seems like a game much better suited to another platform...
I find it difficult to get excited about Zelda when they just showed something so brief. They claim it's open world, but maybe that just means a repeat of WindWaker's terrible sailing to get everywhere.
I find it impossible to get excited about Metal Gear Solid V because all they talk about is how big the world is. Their last demo was Snake riding a horse through a giant world, and they had to speed it up like 8x and it was still boring. I don't understand how having an enormous empty world is a selling point, but that seems like what they are talking about with Metal Gear Solid V...