Page 2 of 3

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Mon Aug 18, 2014 1:48 pm
by matt
Wow! You are extremely thorough. Thank you for the maps! It seems like we have a LOT of bugs relating to shadows. D'oh!

I will go through and fix up the light sources. In most cases, it is just flipping a check box. There are some cases where we don't have a light source like from the bathroom window.I expect the shadow is coming from another light source that shouldn't be casting one.

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 9:44 am
by neuros666
Image
Sec2 :
- The door leading there from Row3 labels it "Block B Security", but the stairwell leading there from Row4 labels it "Block A Security"
Row4 :
- Missing light source from the candle?
Office :
- Extra light source from the leftmost cabinet
Kitchen :
- Extra light source from left wall
Pantry :
- Shadow shows through central front decor
Out :
- Perspective of the shadow from light source at left of the door is off (not sure if can be fixed)

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Wed Aug 20, 2014 6:56 pm
by matt
Okay, these are *mostly* taken care of. There are a few things where I decided to go the other way for your recommendations on the corner lights, but I think the shadows are going to be much better!

I had no idea we had so many hidden light sources behind cabinets and walls. Whoops!

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2014 10:29 am
by neuros666
There are a few things where I decided to go the other way for your recommendations on the corner lights
If you'd care to fill me in, I could tailor my future reports accordingly (unless you want to leave it as a surprise in the next build ;) ).

As for "Together At Last", there were almost no lights to look out for, but I've noticed two things:
  • In the master bedroom, right at the start, is an extra light source from the left wall;
  • In the stairwells, the part of the top door frame closer to the player's view point always shows up behind Thomas; It's hard to notice, and I only could because Thomas was carrying the candle (I could stand on the last step on my way up and see his arm over the door frame).

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Thu Aug 21, 2014 5:50 pm
by matt
It's hard to say exactly why I choose to go a different way on some of the corner lights. Sometimes they aren't close enough to the corner or some other reason that I didn't think it was the best decision.

We have a bug in the database about the stairwell thing. Joe will get around to fixing it... eventually! :)

Good catch though!

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Mon Aug 25, 2014 9:33 am
by neuros666
What I meant is, if you could accurately describe your criteria for having corner lights cast a shadow or not, I could better know whether to report future findings as bugs, or not.

Anyhow, here goes:
Image
Bed1, Bed2, Bed3, Bed4 :
- Missing light sources from middle and rightmost lamps (intentional?)
Boy1, Boy2 :
- Extra light source from left wall
Bath1 :
- Extra light source from left wall
- Extra light source from window (intentional?)
Girl1, Girl2 :
- Extra light source from right wall
Hall2 :
- Extra light source from behind 1st closet
Staircase to Hall5 :
- Steps are of stone but sound like wood
Storage1 :
- Extra light source from right wall?
Office1 :
- Extra light sources from both left & right walls
- Shadows project underneath the desk
Hearth2 :
- Extra light sources from both left & right walls
- Shadows project through elements in front decor
Hall8 & Out :
- Extra light source from left wall
- Missing shadows from path candles?
Bath2 :
- Extra light source from right wall
Hall11 :
- Extra light sources from both left & right walls
- Something weird projects through the caged doll in front decor
Office2 :
- Extra light source from behind the cabinet
Hall11 :
- Extra light sources from both left & right walls
- Shadows project through elements in front decor
Library :
- Shadows project through elements in front decor
Girl3 :
- Extra light sources from both left & right walls
Girl4, Girl5, Girl6 :
- Extra light source from right wall
- Shadows project through elements in front decor
Hall16 :
- Missing light sources from the 1st & 2nd lamps along the planks

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Wed Sep 10, 2014 8:45 am
by neuros666
Hi Matt,

Please just let me know: is it still useful at all if I go on with this?

Thank you,
NeuroS

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Wed Sep 10, 2014 10:06 am
by matt
This is definitely useful! Sorry, I was a bit swamped, so I didn't finish correcting them in the descent level, so I didn't respond, but I'd love to get bugs for the remaining 3 levels. Hopefully we did a better job in those. :)

Thank you so much!

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Fri Sep 12, 2014 9:45 am
by neuros666
Thanks for the feedback; no doubt you have your hands full, it's just nice to know all the work isn't for naught!

Further reports are from v.0.9 build 15044.

Image
Boy1 :
- Extra light source from left wall
- (Fixable?) Shadow projects through the toy chest on the floor
Bath1 :
- Extra light sources from window & right wall
Girl1 :
- Extra light sources from both left & right walls
Hall1 :
- (MAJOR) Missing collision detection on the left wall
- Shadows project through the left wall
Play1 :
- Extra light source from right wall
- Shadows project through rightmost toy chest
Library :
- Shadows project through front decor
Kitchen :
- Extra light source from right wall
Dining :
- Extra light source from left & right walls
- Leftmost cupboard has a collision bounding box, but none of the others do
Hall5 :
- Shadows project through front decor
Hearth :
- Extra light source from left & right walls
- Shadows project through vase in front decor
Hall6 :
- Shadows project through front decor
Bath2 :
- Extra light source from left & right walls
- Extra light source from window
Bed1 :
- Extra light source from left wall
- Missing collision box on closet doors
Hall7 :
- (MAJOR) Extra collision boxes on left wall & door from Bed1 (shadows are cut off)
Cemetary :
- Little Thomas's shadow disappears before that of his plush toy as he approaches the candle at the entrance
- Missing collision box around candle at left of monument (it lies in the path instead of on the side)
Behind mausoleum :
- Z-order bug with a candle at the front

Re: 0.7 - [Minor, visual] Faulty lamp in basement cellar

Posted: Fri Sep 12, 2014 10:48 am
by matt
We've addressed your notes for descent, and I'll pass these along to Joe, so we can get them sorted out.

Thank you so much!